Thursday, June 25, 2020

Holmes Boys

Young Sherlock Holmes (1985) is an interesting piece of 80's cinema, directed by Barry Levinson and written by Chris Columbus, from Spielberg's Amblin Entertainment. The conceit is simple: What if Holmes and Watson had met in school?

Watson joins Holmes at the school he is attending in London, with cots next to each other. Holmes is already a known eccentric and solver of mysteries: the school high-class bully challenges him to a game of deduction, which he solves cleverly. The school also features an eccentric old inventor, a professor-emeritus who keeps trying to fly an ornithopter. He has a niece, played by Sophie Ward, who Holmes is sweet on. She is the only actor in this I think we've seen before, in The Hunger

Meanwhile, there as been a rash of deaths around London - apparent suicides. But we know that a mysterious cloaked figure has been shooting them with drug darts, which cause frightening hallucinations. Holmes thinks these are murders and goes to the police. A certain Lestrade, not yet inspector, doesn't believe him - of course.

This is more of an Indiana Jones with Victorian kids than a mystery of deduction. There's even a Temple of Doom - Pyramid actually. In fact, it's all very 80's kids' adventure. It even has the Spielbergian obsession with explaining how every bit of the mythos came to be: We see the origin of the calabash pipe, the Inverness cape, the deerstalker hat, and even a bit of the violin. Not the coke habit, though. 

I found this to be fun, because I like this type of adventure movie. But it certainly isn't a classic - although it does have some nice hallucinations, including an early CGI stained-glass knight come to life. But if you are a true Baker Street Irregular, you might have trouble with the idea of Holmes with a girlfriend, or of Holmes and Watson meeting before Watson goes to Afghanistan. They actually included disclaimers before and after the film asking forgiveness for this departure from canon.

No comments: